Midgett Realty Hatteras Island Vacation Rentals Logo

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Epicurean Journey to the Best Restaurants on Hatteras Island

HomeAbout AreaJourneys to Hatteras IslandEpicurean Journey to the Best Restaurants on Hatteras Island

Hatteras Island is a destination that has something for everyone to enjoy who heads this way. If you happen to be a traveler who is always on the hunt for fantastic flavors and you have three days to spare, this is the itinerary of the best restaurants on Hatteras Island, designed for you!

Day 1: A Café, Coffee, and Sensational Market Stop

The first day of your Epicurean journey to Hatteras Island begins at Mirro’s Café. Located at 21250 N.C. Highway 12, this charming eatery offers up a casual atmosphere to enjoy breakfast, lunch, or dinner daily. When you come by for breakfast, you can enjoy their savory menu options ranging from biscuit sandwiches and pancakes to breakfast wraps and omelets too. There’s a full kid’s menu if you’re in town with the little ones and the coffee and juices here are the perfect pairing to start your day. Making things even more convenient is the fact that Mirro’s Café is happy to welcome pets for a breakfast experience if you take a seat on their inviting open-air patio!

By mid-day, if you find yourself needing a boost to continue on with the sightseeing and adventures, be sure to make your way to the Dancing Turtle Coffee shop. Located at 57196 Saxon Cut Drive, the Dancing Turtle Coffee Shop is a great place to pick up a mouthwatering espresso, latte, or snack and settle into cozy surroundings in good company to rejuvenate. They’re open from Tuesday through Saturday from 7:00 am until 4:00 pm as well as Sundays until noon.

This evening, dine at the Diamond Shoals Restaurant and Seafood Market at 46843 N.C. Highway 12 in Buxton. This family-owned restaurant has been a staple in the area for over 30 years and invites guests to come and dine in style while also enjoying time browsing their on-site seafood market options. The dinner menu features fantastic clam chowder and crab bisque as well as fresh caught fish of the day. From the salad bar to the sushi bar here, you really can’t go wrong!

Day 2: Seafood and Snacks

The second day of your getaway to Hatteras Island deserves a bit of a sleep in. When you awake well-rested, head over to the Froggy Dog Restaurant & Pub to start things off on a savory note. The Froggy Dog Restaurant & Pub is found at 40050 N.C. Highway 12 in Avon and is a popular seafood stop that comes complete with a ship-themed dining room and pub! It’s an eatery the entire family is sure to love with a menu that features top-notch seafood selections alongside steaks, pasta, burgers, and vegetarian choices as well. The pub hosts locally crafted brews as well as wines from around the world. No matter what you’re craving, this is the place to be.

Because you started the day later, you might not be up for a full meal late in the day which makes the Snack Shack the perfect alternative. Found at 58848 Marina Way, the Snack Shack has been operating in Hatteras Island for more than 11 years and provides both sit-down options as well as quick to-go selections for guests. From their tiki bar to their beachside setting, it’s a casual and comfortable place to come and enjoy some house-made veggie chili or just grab a beer. They have Cuban sandwiches on the menu as well as cole slaw giving this Snack Shack an authentic down-home vibe.

Day 3: The Best Breakfast and a Robust Dinner

The last day of your journey deserves to include sweet and savory moments alike. That’s why you want to head over to Muffins and Scones at 40126 N.C. Highway 12 in Avon first. Here, you can kick things off right with over 17 varieties of New York-style bagels to pick from as well as coffee, muffins, and an array of delicious pastries too. Muffins and Scones also serves up special occasion cakes alongside other gourmet desserts to try. This stop is particularly easy to spot thanks to its bright purple façade!

After you’ve filled your day with stops at local landmarks and attractions, you’ll want to dine at Good Winds Restaurant. Located at 24502 N.C. Highway 12 in Rodanthe, Good Winds Restaurant pairs an impeccable menu of delicious options with stunning waterfront views too. Fresh caught fish of the day is a popular choice here but it’s hard to overlook their impressive wine listings. Good Winds Restaurant sits just above Kitty Hawk Kites and is a great place to catch a day three sunset as well.

Book Your Hatteras Island Adventure Today

When you’re ready to turn those Hatteras Island vacation plans into an exciting reality, the team at Midgett Realty is here to make sure you have incredible accommodations in place to top off your stay in style. Reach out today to learn more about our many inviting and exciting options available. We can’t wait to help elevate your stay with just the right vacation rental and look forward to seeing you here soon on your journey to enjoy the best restaurants on Hatteras Island!